How to Recognize Leadership Potential Before a Promotion

The person who's best at the job is often the first person considered for a promotion. In architecture, engineering, and other professional services firms, that usually means someone with strong technical skills, a reputation for reliability, and the ability to deliver good work consistently.

It's a reasonable starting point. But being good at the work and being ready to take responsibility for the work of others are two different things.

Some of the strongest individual contributors struggle when their responsibilities expand. Meanwhile, people who haven't yet distinguished themselves as technical experts may already be demonstrating the judgment, initiative, and influence needed to lead. The challenge is recognizing those qualities before a promotion makes them necessary.

Look Beyond Technical Performance

Technical performance is relatively easy to observe. Projects get completed, deadlines are met, and clients are satisfied. Leadership potential is harder to see because it often shows up in smaller moments that don't appear on a performance review.

Think about the employee who notices a coordination problem before it becomes a schedule issue. Or the person who recognizes that two colleagues are working from different assumptions and brings them together to resolve the confusion. Neither action necessarily requires exceptional technical expertise, but both demonstrate an ability to see beyond an individual assignment.

Research by Robert Katz, published in Harvard Business Review in 1955, distinguished among technical, human, and conceptual skills in effective administration. His framework remains useful because it reminds us that the capabilities needed to perform specialized work aren't identical to those needed to coordinate people, understand larger systems, and exercise organizational judgment.

For growing firms, this distinction matters. Promoting someone solely because they're the strongest technical performer can leave an important development gap unaddressed.

Pay Attention to How People Handle Uncertainty

Leadership potential often becomes visible when the instructions run out. A client changes direction, a project encounters an unexpected constraint, or two priorities begin competing for the same resources. Some employees wait for someone else to decide what happens next. Others begin exploring options, asking better questions, and helping the team find a way forward.

The difference isn't necessarily confidence or personality. It's the willingness to engage with a situation that doesn't have an obvious answer.

Leadership researchers Morgan McCall, Michael Lombardo, and Ann Morrison explored the importance of developmental experiences in their 1988 book The Lessons of Experience. Their work highlighted how challenging assignments and consequential experiences contribute to managerial development.

Rather than waiting until someone receives a leadership title, managers can observe how employees respond to unfamiliar situations today. Do they recognize what has changed? Can they distinguish an urgent problem from a minor inconvenience? Are they able to recommend a reasonable next step?

These are useful signals of emerging judgment, although no single situation should determine someone's future.

Notice Who Makes Others More Effective

Leadership isn't only about individual decisions. It also involves helping other people accomplish something together.

An employee who shares information early, helps a colleague understand a difficult issue, or brings clarity to a confused team may be exercising more leadership than someone who simply completes a larger volume of work.

In their research on informal leadership, organizational scholars have examined how influence can emerge through everyday interactions rather than formal authority. People often become influential because others trust their judgment, seek their perspective, or rely on them to help move work forward.

These contributions are easy to overlook in organizations that primarily reward individual productivity. Yet they're often the behaviors that make teams more effective as responsibilities become more complex.

Give People Opportunities to Show What They Can Do

Recognizing leadership potential shouldn't become another exercise in labeling people. A better approach is to create opportunities for employees to demonstrate and develop their capacity through real work.

Ask someone to lead a coordination meeting, manage a difficult handoff, recommend a solution to a project problem, or take responsibility for a small outcome. Give them enough authority to exercise judgment, then discuss what happened and what they learned.

At CGILITY, we call this everyday leadership. People develop their capacity to lead by understanding how they contribute, recognizing what situations require, and taking action that creates impact. Those opportunities exist long before someone becomes a manager.

A promotion shouldn't be the first time an employee is expected to demonstrate leadership. It should recognize capabilities they've already begun developing.

The question isn't simply who performs best today. It's who is showing the capacity to take on more tomorrow.

—

References

  • Katz, R. L. (1955). Skills of an Effective Administrator. Harvard Business Review. Establishes the distinction between technical, human, and conceptual management skills.

  • McCall, M. W., Lombardo, M. M., & Morrison, A. M. (1988). The Lessons of Experience: How Successful Executives Develop on the Job. Lexington Books. Examines the role of challenging experiences in developing managerial capability.

  • DeRue, D. S., & Ashford, S. J. (2010). Who Will Lead and Who Will Follow? A Social Process of Leadership Identity Construction in Organizations. Academy of Management Review, 35(4), 627–647. Provides a research foundation for understanding how leadership emerges through social interactions and recognition, rather than formal titles alone.

Next
Next

How to Delegate Responsibility, Not Just Tasks